1. Home
  2. Cities & Towns
  3. Huntsville, AL
Huntsville Restaurant Review--Main Street Cafe
Restaurant:  Madison Street Cafe
101 Main St, Madison AL
Phone:  256-461-8096
Hrs. 11:00 – 2:00 pm Mon-Sat
 More of this Feature
More Restaurant Reviews
Health Dept. Ratings
Local Recipes
Just for Fun 
  Related Resources
• Dining in Huntsville
• Day Trips
• Entertainment
 
 

From:  Cathey Carney

Rating:     

A few weeks ago, six reviewers decided to try out the new Main Street Café, to see if it measured up to the rave reviews we had heard previously. 

Dale Cassidy of Madison works for Agilent Technologies, as does Phyllis Rogers of Grant.  Mary Barksdale, from Decatur, works for Hewlett-Packard Co., Lee Lanier working for ADL lives here in Huntsville.  Joan Priest lives in Kelso, Tennessee and works for Agilent, also.  Cathey Carney of Hewlett-Packard and Old Huntsville magazine brought her camera to take pictures of the group. 

We arrived at 11:10 – early so as to get a good seat.  Parking is a problem – you may have to drive around a bit.  It was already packed, and stayed that way during the entire lunch.  The waitress came right over, gave us excellent service the entire hour, even though she was very busy with her tables. The building is in the old Madison Jail and city hall, and has been renovated in a very quaint manner. 

Now to the food.  First of all, we had to try the hot spice tea and it was excellent – a secret mixture but delicious.  Then we checked out the menu and decided on our entrees.  None of the selections cost over $7.45, and there were a couple written on a board at the front of the restaurant – however, we chose off the menu.  3 of us chose the “Miss Daisy’s Beef Casserole”, beef baked with mushrooms, tomatoes, water chestnuts, noodles and cheese, served with house salad and hot yeast roll.  This got excellent reviews from all who chose it – flavorful, hot, in a bowl with a wonderful, fresh yeast roll like you used to get at the Bon Aire Restaurant. 

Cathey chose the Poulet de Normandie, which was baked chicken cooked into a wonderful dressing mixed with mushroom sauce and melting cheese, served with hot green beans, an excellent cranberry congealed salad and a giant yeast roll.  All of the portions were just right, everyone was full including our male guest Lee. 

Lee chose the Chicken and Broccoli Casserole, stating that it was one of the best chicken casseroles he had ever had.  It was combined with a cream sauce with just a hint of curry., green beans came with it and a giant Yeast Roll!  You can tell the yeast rolls won the votes of All our group.  Those who got salads claimed that they were very fresh and crispy, and especially liked the Bleu Cheese dressing.

We had heard about the Strawberry Pretzel Salad dessert so 3 of us tried that, with one diving into the Mississippi Mud Cake, and one trying the Derby Pie.  The smallest of all was the Derby pie, that would seem like a Pecan pie without the pecans, with a chocolate crust and chocolate chips on the bottom.  It was rich but delicious. 

The Mississippi Mud Cake was a chocoholics delight, large and oozing with rich chocolate and a layer of marshmallow cream.  But the Strawberry Pretzel dessert was delightful – a crust made of crushed pretzels and who-knows-what-else, topped with thick strawberry Jell-O with an inch layer of what tasted like sweetened cream cheese.    It was Heaven and a perfect end to an excellent meal! 

Note:  The restaurant is only open until 2:00 – so my advice – go early, just to make sure you get parked and seated.  They are open for dinner Tuesdays through Saturdays from 5 to 9 p.m.  And Main Street Café does accept reservations, which is rare nowadays.

More Reviews........More Food........More Opinions.......More Fun.........More Eating......

More Main Street  Health Dept. Ratings

click here to submit your rating
More Reviews
Restaurant Reviews in the Forum

Huntsville Events Calendar

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

 

Previous Articles

Explore Huntsville, AL

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Cities & Towns
  3. Huntsville, AL

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.