Ben Holmes plays Beth's little brother, Charlie and John Willuhn plays the father, Bob Bradley, who reluctantly agrees to attend this year's "Pageant" since his wife is directing it. Sarah Nunn portrays Alice, the "perfect" little girl found in every Sunday School class who usually ends up as "Mary" in the Christmas pageant. Much to her consternation, Imogene Herdman wrestles her for the role this year. Nunn does a great job conveying the spirit of Alice to the audience.
Other students playing main characters include Allison Lott as maxine, Richard Davis as Elmer, Ryan Balch as David, Anthony Chang as Hobie, Danae Williams as Beverly, Holli McCluney as Baby Angel Shirley and Danielle Mason as Baby Angel Juanita. Caitlin Still is Doris.